Midnight Eye
the latest and best in Japanese cinema
home interviews features film reviews book reviews calendar links about contact
The Mermaid in the Manhole (1991) The Mermaid in the Manhole (1991)
Manhoru No Naka No Ningyo
Hideshi HINO
Shigeru SAIKI
57 mins.
The Mermaid in the Manhole (1991)

The Guinea Pig series is one of the most infamous examples of what is seen as the depraved nature of Japanese popular culture. It gained its notoriety when actor Charlie Sheen was allegedly shown a copy of part 2, Flower of Flesh and Blood, the story of a deranged murderer who dissects a young woman in his basement one bit at a time in gory, graphic detail, and believed it to be a genuine snuff film.

Sheen reported his concerns to the FBI, who undertook a thorough investigation before arriving at the inevitable conclusion that the film was a fake. The deed was already done however and cultural xenophobes had found more proof that the minds of the Japanese were depraved and corrupted, while Western gorehounds had another title to put at the top of their wish lists.

The Guinea Pig films were in fact a series of shot-on-video short features, averaging about an hour in length each, devised by producer Satoru Ogura. Part 2 was directed by manga artist Hideshi Hino, who was known in the West for his critically praised comic book Panorama of Hell. Hino's effort provoked police investigations in both the US and Japan, where Flower of Flesh and Blood was thought to be connected to a serial killer case. The rumour goes that in an attempt to dispell the notion that the Guinea Pig films were genuine snuff, producer Ogura created a 'making of' episode documenting the creation of the films' make-up and gore effects, courtesy of fx artist Nobuaki Koga. Shortly thereafter Orange Video House, the production company behind Guinea Pig, went bust and the rights were acquired by distributors JHV. Though initially retaining Hino and Ogura at the helm, the series went into different territories as the films became more plot-driven, more humorous and generally traded the gory for the absurd.

The first of the JHV cycle, episode four in total, was once again directed by Hideshi Hino. To the surprise of many, Hino delivered a film which was rich in themes and subtexts and which, despite being incredibly graphic, wasn't about violence at all. With The Mermaid in the Manhole the director above all chose to explore the theme of human obsession and devotion which go beyond sickness, decay and death.

The story concerns a painter whose wife has recently left him. He devotes all his time and attention to his art, venturing into the sewers beneath his house in search of inspiration for his paintings, which all depict scenes of decay and disease. Once this sewer was a river, where the painter played as a child and where he once believed to have seen a mermaid. On one of his treks he realises his beliefs were right when he finds the mermaid, trapped in the stinking sewer. When the river ran dry, she explains, she was unable to get back to sea and hid in the sewer system. Her skin badly infected by waste and pollution after years of living in the sewer, she begs the painter to help her. He decides to take her to his house, where he puts her in his bathtub and proceeds to paint her.

Her condition worsens and after a while festering sores start erupting all over her body. Though both of them know death is inevitable, the mermaid asks the artist to document her decay in his painting. This he does and the bond between the two grows stronger as her situation deteriorates. When the sores increase, he adjusts his portrait accordingly, even when the infection turns into a grotesque mutation that covers her entire body. When he fails to find the right paint to truthfully depict the colours of her infections, she tells him to slice open the boils with a razor blade and use the abundantly flowing puss instead.

The Mermaid in the Manhole is a perverted fairy tale, but one which exists to celebrate the spiritual connections which can exist between two people. It celebrates love and devotion, between two human beings, but also between the artist and his art and between the artist and his muse. Throwing in comments on environmental pollution and a Cronenberg-esque fascination for disease and the frailty of the human body (also an important factor in his two earlier Guinea Pig outings), Hideshi Hino has created an absorbing and fascinating study of obsession and deep-rooted devotion. Yes, the graphic depictions of disease, decay and butchery are unflinching and no doubt they will be too much to stomach for many. But at its core, The Mermaid in the Manhole displays an unexpected richness which make it a highly rewarding experience. For those with the stomach to sit it through.

copyright 2001-2005 Midnight Eye